Associative Trails / writing

Nobody petitioned against Netflix

Your relatives have good reasons to distrust data centres. One Swedish town shows what earning that trust looks like.

Public hostility to data centres is real, and it will be discussed at the festive dinner table. This post argues that the hostility is rational. The industry hid both the work and the cost, broke promises to the towns it built in, and is now asking for trust it has not earned.

Sheet 41 · AI
ByMatt Perdeaux
Published19 Nov 2026
Reading6 min
The claimThe hostility is a shortage of trust, not of information

Last week a relative forwarded me an Avaaz petition. Its title: “Nature, not data centres!”. Below it sat a big, scary number: 250,000 trees, cleared by Google for an AI data centre in Finland.

With Christmas coming up, if you work in technology, you know what comes next. Somewhere between you having to connect the printer and getting Alexa to stop playing Mariah Carey, the conversation turns to AI, and you become the unofficial spokesperson for every despicable thing done by any American technology firm.

A family Christmas dinner table seen from one end, with a large windowless data centre visible through the window behind it.
Your Grandad remembers the view before the data centre.

The easy response is to correct the details. But your relative is not misinformed. They have just stopped trusting the people doing the informing.

Jasmine Sun went to Michigan and Wisconsin to find out who opposes data centres and why. She told Odd Lots that the protestors were well-informed and could tell closed-loop cooling from open-loop as well as the companies trying to build it. Their objection was not technical. The local utility company had raised rates in four of the past five years, and the jobs Foxconn promised never came. Sun calls it the trust gap: a shortage not of information, but of belief.

“I would say the gap among anti data center activists was much more about trust than it was about information.”
Jasmine Sun, on Odd Lots
01The forest was cleared before the assessment was finished

The petition is mostly right

So I checked. Google is planning nine data centre buildings near Muhos, in northern Finland, and by its own figure has cleared 330 hectares of forest there, topsoil included. The 250,000 trees are an estimate from the Finnish Association for Nature Conservation, not an official count.

Finnish law requires an environmental assessment before more than 200 hectares of forest is permanently removed. The regulator, LVV, told Muhos in May not to grant any permit until that assessment was finished, and Muhos says it granted none. LVV ordered the work stopped on 6 October. Google's country manager apologised a week later. Google says the building law allowed felling before construction. LVV disagrees and has asked the police to investigate. Until a court decides, “illegal” is the petition’s word, not yet the law’s.

But look at what the petition actually asks for: a pause until "strong environmental and community protections are in place and enforced". Muhos had the protection. It lacked the enforcement.

02Twenty years of hiding the work also hid the cost

Data centres are not new

Data centres have run your banking, your email and your streaming for twenty years, and nobody petitioned against Netflix. There were some objections. Amsterdam paused new data centres in 2019. In 2022, months before ChatGPT, Meta dropped its Zeewolde campus in the Netherlands after local opposition. The AI label took a local grievance international. In this month’s US midterms, data centres were on the ballot in 41 places across 10 states. Voters went against the industry in all but one.

40 of 41

local ballot measures on data centres went against the industry in the 2026 US midterms, across 10 states.

CNBC count, reported by Futurism, 5 November 2026

Part of the reason is the industry's own doing. In September, I wrote about why hard things look easy - software has spent decades presenting itself as magic, hiding the complexity wherever it could. The trouble with hiding the work is that you also hide the cost. People never saw the colossal industrial buildings behind their bank app. The first ones they notice are being sold to them as AI.

And what does AI look like from the dinner table? What has it done for them lately? Better-written spam, deepfakes in the family group chat, and a steady supply of stories about jobs disappearing. Sun heard the same in Michigan - why should a town take "the hit of having this giant, ugly thing" so that coding agents can help people in San Francisco make more apps?

03NDAs and lawsuits lost towns; Falun's council built its own

Every response has made it worse

The industry's responses have widened the gap - each one confirmed what the sceptics already suspected. Developers asked towns to sign NDAs, and Sun says every pro-data-centre person she met now regrets it. In Saline Township, Michigan, the board voted against a data centre for OpenAI’s Stargate project, the developer sued, and the township settled.

Each move is understandable, from the big tech point of view. Secrecy protects a deal from rivals. A lawsuit protects an investment. And a manifesto is cheaper than a negotiation. That is perhaps why Jason Calacanis read Mark Zuckerberg's recent AI essay as a trade - free tools, and "the only thing we ask in return is that you let us build some data centres." Google's apology came after the Finnish forest had already been dug up.

But there is another way. EcoDataCenter in Falun, Sweden, was started by the local council in 2010, long before the AI boom. It is built from timber, runs on hydro and wind power, and feeds its waste heat into the town’s district heating. The company told the Guardian that 90% of its suppliers are local, and 60% of its capital spending stays in the area.

“It’s very hard to develop something in Sweden where there’s not a consensus.”
John Wernvik, EcoDataCenter, in the Guardian
04People believe their own experience over a list of benefits

Explaining the benefits is not enough

Back at the Christmas Day dinner table, it's tempting to list what AI already does for your sceptical relatives. It is why the bank texts before a stolen card gets used, why most phishing emails never reach their inbox, and why their phone can find every photo of the dog. It captions their video calls and takes down millions of violent videos before anyone sees them. Explain that, and surely they will come round.

Nilay Patel at The Verge thinks not. "You can't advertise people out of reacting to their own experiences," he wrote in April. On The Vergecast after the midterms he was blunter: you cannot ask people to live next to a loud data centre in return for AI Overviews and deepfakes. People need evidence they can see for themselves.

Satya Nadella, Microsoft’s chief executive, told Davos in January that unless AI improves people’s health and education, the industry will “quickly lose even the social permission” to use the energy it needs. That trust is earned town by town, before the trees are felled.

Until it is, you are the industry’s representative at the dinner table. Set up the printer anyway. Queue up Low's Christmas Album. Trust gets built one small job at a time.

If you would like to talk through how to bring the AI sceptics in your firm with you, please do get in touch.

Get in touch